His alleged point was that we all wanted a graphical update to a 12 year old game and were willing to wait eight years for it. Honestly though, it’s the tweaks to the gameplay and new puzzles I liked the most. Questionable Ethics was a huge high point of the remake for me.
If we just wanted visual updates and nothing else then the point would be valid. But the considerable changes to the gameplay that still “fit” with the feel of the original HL should distinguish it from simple “graphics whoring.”
I love the original HL as well, play it a bunch. So that shouldn’t apply.
Also, got to Asteroid Coaster in Sonic Colors. The level design here is INSANITY. Love it.