Hi, just delurking to voice my support for J-Dude and explain a few things.
Of course, in the most obvious, legal sense, the developers of BMS owe us nothing. That is true. That is also a statement so obvious it borders on irrelevant. Of course, whenever somebody says “They owe us a demo” or “They owe us at least a news post”, they are in no way talking about a legal obligation. They are talking about faith and credibility.
Let’s ask a harsh question here: What have the developers done for us, to date, that we can verify? In total, provided a site, some bitching pictures, an admittedly utterly kick-ass trailer, and a lot of promise. In return, many regulars have placed an investment that is no less real for not being physical: an investment of faith. They have spread the word, they have given feedback, all based on nothing but faith.
It is this faith that the developers, according to the critics, risk losing by missing deadlines. It is this faith that the use of the word “owe” is based on - of course, the developers are under no obligation to do anything - they could pack up and go home whenever they want, and throw that faith away. But, and that’s what I’m reading in the critics’ posts, if they are interested in keeping that faith, some amount of courtesy such as more insight into the mod’s progress, more frequent frontpage updates (the latest news are still the trailer, for christ’s sake!), and most importantly, not missing deadlines, would go a long way.
And yes, Valve miss deadlines too. You know what? Valve can afford to miss deadlines. Valve have proven, time and time again, that when they release a game it’ll be good - this is why they have the faith of the fanbase, deadlines be damned. And, I’m sorry to say this, but the BMS team has not done that. They’ve done nothing, to date, to deserve that kind of faith from their fans, and they won’t have done it until there is playable media available for download.
Until then, I’ll look towards the mod with a little less interest, but still a hell of a lot of anticipation. Don’t get me wrong - I still have faith, warranted or not, in the BMS team and I’m sure the mod, whenever it’ll come out, will be great.
Others don’t have that faith, and that’s fine too. It’s what this topic is about. Don’t flame them for their opinion.