I’ll start with my worst…
The day that IGN.com gave Halo the “Game of the Year” award. I was like Halo!? WTF? Really? In 2001 a lot of great games were released, including some mold-breaking ones…and an FPS with NO online capabilities, boring enemies, and a lame selection of guns wins GOTY?!
Hell, even Perfect Dark was a better game, and it was released a year and 1/2 earlier for a system a whole console generation older. Sure the N64 lacked the graphical power the Xbox had, but PD had gobs more features. PD had all kinds of customizable multiplayer modes, an incredible selection of guns, a ton of great maps, and up to 8 fully customizable bots.
Sure, I know I’m not talking about the 2000 GOTY awards, but shouldn’t the 2001 winner either be a great game with an incredible new play style, one that created a new genre, or one that represented a dramatic improvement for an existing genre? Halo wasn’t any of those.
Hell, here’s some games that came out in 2001:
Grand Theft Auto III
Conker’s Bad Fur Day
Black & White
Super Monkey Ball
Gran Turismo 3
Devil May Cry
Ico
Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty
Civilization III
All those games, especially GTA III, and an inferior FPS wins GOTY? Bite my balls!