So I went poking around the Zune Media Player today…
First things first, I ran a speed test. Cold start up to playing music for Zune was exactly the same time (roughly 7 seconds) as for iTunes. Zune started up faster but took a second to load the funky music playing screen.
A few comments on cosmetics: The Zune player looks much nicer than iTunes does. The nice coverart background in the player screen is superb, compared to the, well, nothing in iTunes. But functionality wise, its pretty much exactly the same. The Quickplay screen just shows the equivalent of your ‘My Top Rated’, ‘Recently Added’ and ‘Recently Played’ playlists in iTunes. Nothing new here.
As much as people rave about its snazzy looks, if you look at the ‘collection’ screen, its like you’ve jumped straight back into iTunes. You can sort the lists by Artist, Genre, Album and Song Title, exactly the same way you can in iTunes. Except that in iTunes you can also sort by a whole range of other criterion, such as Year, Date Added and even Bit Rate.
I also noticed a few things when I went digging around in the more technical aspects of the Zune player. Importing songs was the thing that got me; in iTunes you can import in MP3, AAC, AIFF, Apple Lossless and Wave straight out of the box, and even convert any music to any of those formats very easily. In Zune you’re limited to MP3 or WMA (which means you’re basically limited to MP3), and you can’t convert between formats.
I can’t speak to how Zune manages its library, since I was always happy for iTunes to do it itself and don’t want to screw anything up, but I’ve heard that that’s better for those that want that kind of functionality.
Anyway, that’s just my observations for now. Will post back when I have more.

