So I had been playing games that require it, like Arkham Asylum and GTAIV, perfectly fine until I started Red Faction Guerrilla. It had me create another Live ID plus an Xbox Live ID to play. And now when I just started up GTAIV it started a new game. I want to continue from where I left off with, though. Any ideas on how to fix this?
Edit: I don’t remember creating the first one. It was just there when I started the game up. I had to actively create this second one.