The game is so much more gorgeous than I thought it would be - and I already thought it was going to be gorgeous. The graphics are stellar and the Homeworld 1 ships look completely glorious. It’s clear a huge amount of love has been put into the visuals and the presentation.
I wish some of that effort had been diverted into the gameplay design. There’s a lot of gameplay detail from HW1 which has just been dropped or doesn’t work properly - the MP at the moment I would say is very mediocre with regards to the HW1 races, it’s not really even close to how HW1 played. The fact that formations basically might as well not even exist is a major bummer and makes larger scale strike craft battles IMPOSSIBLE to read and very confusing. Resource, construction speeds and research speeds work like HW2, so when playing the HW1 races you basically can just spam crazy amounts of units of any type. All the multiplayer games where I’ve played the HW1 races I pretty much just spam Frigates to great effect. Again, they play totally like HW2 Frigates in that they’re glass cannons and are extremely expendable.
I was so excited for the combined multiplayer idea but I don’t think it’s very good. It is a beta though, and balancing the 4 races with one another was always going to be extremely challenging. It will undoubtedly improve.
Personally I really wanted something with HW:R’s graphical fidelity which played very close to HW1, because I think most people would agree its MP design was far superior to HW2, and was much deeper and had far more strategy than HW2’s rock paper scissors unit spam. Unfortunately it really is a HW2ified version of HW1. However - Gearbox/what’s left of the original Homeworld team clearly loved the game greatly and may be far more limited by the engine and timing than we realise (trust me, the BMS team know greatly the challenges of dealing with a restrictive engine). I’m hopeful they can bring back more of Homeworld 1’s gameplay details and design, over time, particularly if we’re vocal about it. At the very least, the formations HAVE to work properly!
At any rate, I’m just delighted that people love and care about this series and that it might have a future. It’s still fantastic and I am really happy with it despite my complaints.