my personal ranking:
#1 Tau Cannon (HL1, awesome soundeffects, awesome movement, awesome gamestyle possibilities, loved to wallspam all the spawns on crossfire :> )
#2 Long Jump Module
#3 Crossbow (HL1, liked how the bow worked in HL1DM)
#4 Glock (HL1, love the sounds and fire modes…)
#5 MP5 Grenades (HL1, like how they fly through the air spinning around themselves… makes me wanna fire them all the time…)
#6 RPG (HL1, love controling rockets with the laser… found it useful to be able to turn off laserdot)
#7 EGON! :> (cool sound, fkn powerful, fkn annoying… fkn GREAT [maybe a bit overpowered… but ok… i hope it will have a cool down function or need more ammo in bms… otherwise it will be too spamy)
#8 Sporelauncer (HL1:Op4)
#7 SATCHEL (HL1… found them way more effective than HL2 SLAMS)
#8 Barnacle (HL1:Op4, nice hook-function)
#9 357 Revolver (HL2, liked it more because of its animations… less annoying than the HL1 fidget animation… but I liked HL1’s 357 zoom function… Missed it in HL2)
#10 Crowbar (HL1, loved its attackspeed… even if it was a bit unrealistic… and liked the animations)
#11 Tripmines (HL1, loved to trip-mine climb on some maps)
#12 Snarks
#13 Shotgun (HL1, better ammolimit, better animations)
#14 Hornet (HAHAHAH beeeeeessss )
#15 Shovel (HL2:Smod )