I am currently debating (internally) over whether I should play a Fallout game. I’ve heard great things about it from sources I don’t trust, and nothing from sources that I do. So I turn it to you at the BM Forums.
It looks like the art is good throughout, but it seems a little gimmicky to me. And not in the 50’s style way that BioShock adopted (I love BioShock for mainly this reason,) it’s seems like the notion of 50’s style is there, but after a while it’s ignored, and the game exchanges it’s emphasis on a great setting for less artsy, more mainstream ‘kickin-ass’ stuff.
I like the FPS/RPG genre a whole lot, and I have no reason to think the gameplay isn’t fun, but some elements seem annoying to me, like feeding yourself apparently as often as a Sims character, and a ‘karma’ system, seem silly. (EDIT) I also heard once that the whole game is an endless menu screen, which would be… not good.
I also have no knowledge as to what the story is like. For a sandbox game, it may well suck, but just out of my curiosity, a ‘yay’ or ‘nay’ would help me.
Remember, this is all what I’ve gathered from a first-impression. I may be very wrong, and if so, please correct me ^^