Ask a Muslim!

I don’t know why my first thread got deleted but anyways ,as I said before : after the events of 11\9 people started to Hijack in an unbelievable ways Islam and muslims all around the world and for what ? "just because there are certain group “AL-Qaeda” Blow up and kill innocent people even Muslims ,that doesn’t mean they represent Islam or Muslims. if you have any questions regarding Islam I’ll be more than Glad to answer “with my personal experience and knowledge”

p.s Please people keep it Civil and be open-minded

edit : oh BTW Muslims believe in evolution and science but not that Humans were evolved from Apes

My education on this matter said that the problem with Koran (the holy book of Islam) is that it is reorganized from shortest to longest texts, while they were written in different order. This may then lead to confusion if you don’t read the texts chronologically, but in the current ordering.

Another thing to understand is that the time in which some of the more “aggresive” texts were written, the prophet might have needed justification for assaulting distant lands (Mecca?), so he basically wrote the passages of “If you don’t convert an infidel to your faith, you have to kill him” etc.

Beyond these aggresive texts, Islam is a religion of peace and compassion, it even explicitly says that you should donate 1/40 of your gains for charity.

Just as any other religion, in the hands of the power-greedy or violence-seeking people, it may turn into an incentive to do horrible things. But if you for instance look at the example of the great king Salahadin (Saladin), you will see that even in the heat of war, a wise educated muslim will be able to tell the difference between good and bad people.

It was witnessed that when the movie “Kingdom of Heaven” was played in theatres (cinemas) in the muslim world, most of the audience cheered and applauded in the scene where Salahadin, after conquering Jerusalem, picks up from ground, and respectfully places on a table, a christian cross.

Because it almost immediately turned into a flaming contest. If you’re going to post in these ‘Ask a…’ threads keep it civil. I’ll be watching.

that is perfectly normal thing to do,in fact we were told to respect people of book “Christians and Jews” cause they believe in the same God and we can even Marry from them

as for the “aggressive texts” will to be honest ,the Quran is written in Pure Arabic and only a handful of people can understand the exact meaning of a particular verse ,and it’s hard to translate it to another language

am fine with it :slight_smile:

Good idea for a thread, I like these. I don’t have any questions at the moment, but isn’t it technically true that humans didn’t evolve from apes? We evolved from simian creatures who looked like apes, but were part of the homo genus and are now the only surviving members. I don’t know if you meant apes literally, or just simian primates in general.

no we believe that God created us and perfected us ,he says in the Quran that we are his best creation ,

as for the evolution ,we believe in natural selection and the evolving of lotta of animals and organisms :wink:

I’m a bit ill equipped to discuss this topic, as I know little of the Muslim beliefs. But, if I have this right, other animals evolved. Humans didn’t / don’t? Now we know for a fact humans DO evolve. We have seen our immune system change and become more efficient. How is this addressed? As a note, this isn’t theory. This is accepted truth…

now that’s a smart question :slight_smile:

to answer it ,I do believe we evolved in a way to adapt our surroundings ,like the people that lives in very Cold areas ,adapted to the harsh environment they live in and if they went to really hot areas ,they’ll Die and vice versa

Like I said we believe that we were created this way “our current look” and stayed like this to this day

oh and here is a cool verse that “roughly” translate into : “we created Man Kind in best posture”

now what that means that since god created us we were always standing upright :smiley:

like we are the only “earthly” creations that stands upright and we should be honored to be created that way

So you don’t understand most of the Qur’an at all, but you believe in the faith anyway?

no man I do :slight_smile: ,it’s just I can’t translate it “purely” into English cause that is way to hard and like I said it’s written in pure Arabic ,and that requires a really experienced language experts to do so

I have read the Quran and lotta of Hadiths

@Dill: He may not understand the language, but with research into different translations a message can become clear.

So, it can be accepted that man evolves, but he is still man. It’s difficult to debate this with accurate evidence because of the incomplete fossil record. However, given evidence available, it seems more likely to me that it a progression. Now I can’t defend a lot of detail here, because I don’t really know too much about what I would be defending against. Dialog with me here is going to be limited.

that’s ok man ,I liked your question ,if there is anything else crosses your mind be sure to point it out

is it me or is the muslim faith currently seeing alot of “joy riders”? And by “joy riders” I mean the kind of people who don’t actually believe in the religon, only vaguely know about it, but say they are muslim because it’s a cool thing to bitch about how your victimised in social situations, attention whoring basically. And if so, religous or not, doesn’t that grind anyone elses gears?

Like Christianity and Judaism don’t have that already ?

true true, I just really hate pretenders and attention whores

Are you a Sunni or a Shi’it?
Other than Ali’s succession row, what are the differences?
Personally, why do you partain to one form over the other?

Well I’m pretty fuzzy on my knowledge of the Muslim religion. I’m not sure I get the concept that Islam existed before Mohammad. I’m also a little unclear about something that was mentioned to me saying that Being a Muslim isn’t so much about the beliefs themselves, but rather a state of being. I’m not sure what this means.

I am Sunni ,will the story of Shi’ts goes way back , they disapprove of Mohammad and said that Gabriel has lost his way and went down to Mohammad instead of Ali ,and they say Mohammad’s wife (Aisha) was a whore

Shadi, I have often wondered if some Muslims view some of the Muslim extremists as we Christians view the Christian extremists the same way.

To me, the “Christian” groups that picket funerals, kill abortionists, scream hatred of homosexuals and such things are a real sore spot for other peace loving Christians. They do not represent the true meaning of Christs teachings and I know we prefer to not have anything to do with folks that actively partake in such hate mongering.

I wonder if your teachings and and upbringings in relation to the extremists gives you the same sense of … well for a lack of a better word… facepalming… that we Christians get?

I’m sure they do, I don’t accept extremist “Christians” as Christians. they are not, plain and simple.

for a question? hmm. ok, now I had heard somewhere that it was not traditionally acceptable for muslims to be friends (not including aquantances of course) with people of other religion. (Jews, Christians, Atheists, Buddists)

Is this true?

Founded in 2004, Leakfree.org became one of the first online communities dedicated to Valve’s Source engine development. It is more famously known for the formation of Black Mesa: Source under the 'Leakfree Modification Team' handle in September 2004.