So, I just tried to watch Battlestar Galactia again, and only managed to get an hour into the first episode, but I’ve finally managed to pin down the exact reason why I don’t like it: it’s way, way, too ‘darker and edgier’.
They’re gone completely overboard in trying to make it dark and mature. The plot is a near constant stream of ‘serious adult themes’ happening for no good reason: Drug addiction, rape, murder, breast cancer. The characters themselves are incredibly dysfunctional and volatile, and feel like they’re constantly on the verge of lashing out at everyone around them - which they do.
I really, really want to like this show, but I just can’t. It’s an overblown soap opera, and I want a space opera.

not being able to trust someone I’ve trusted for so long.